RE: Star Trek: Beyond
Two times I very briefly had to step out during the movie. I guess that was when the few seconds of girl power moment that you guys are talking about happened.
I believed they sent multiple probes; the previous Magellan probes that crashed on the planet are some of them, Enterprise clearly had the telemetry data uploaded before Magellan probe lost contact. It will also makes sense that they will download the alien female's ship database to access for navigation purposes.
Of course the swarm made it through, they are able to send a lone scout ship through with the alien female. Just because the people of the Enterprise thinks it is impossible, doesn't mean it is for everybody. Of course the Franklin made it through; she crashed her way through the first time, the ship computer had all the navigational data when it crashed its way through the first time. All they had to do is retrace their steps + follow the path of the swarm + a few minor corrections.
You seem to be unnecessarily nitpicking this shit. Don't know why.
The Aliens are immune to Star Fleet weapons because they know their shields frequencies and weapons calibration. That is how the Borg collective were able to adapt to Federations weapons: modifying their weapons parameters to render Federations offensive and defensive capabilities useless. This is one of the weaknesses of energy weapons. The Aliens in this movie are able to do the same because they've already hacked all Federations databases.
The Alien ships exploded because they WERE CRASHING into each other due to massive disruption in their communication. If you are flying huge swarms at extremely high velocity in super tight formations, and they require that communication to function, organize, and re-orient themselves with supreme precision. If you disrupt that communication, they will all start colliding into each other, there will be massive explosions.
Scotty intergalatic transporter crashed with the enterprise.
They rest of starfleet did something: they played the beastie boys music to wipe clean the alien swarm.
The Alien's woman mentioned that Krall is holding her crew hostage in the same place Krall is holding hostage the Enterprise crew.
Spock is half-human, and he was delirious with massive blood loss at the point of death.
So Kahn's blood can regenerate necrotic tissue. What relevance does this have to do with this movie? Use Kahn's blood to regenerate necrotized body of hundreds of dead crew members during that massive battle chaos that was going on? You want them to fit that into the movie at that point in time?
Marcus daughter is not there. So? There was this hot green alien from the last movie that wasn't in this movie too. So? Besides, Spock pointed out that having Marcus daughter onboard is very redundant because they already have him. Not just that, it will make sense for her to want to leave, since her father caused the massive deaths of fellow crew members onboard. I won't want to hang around the Enterprise after that, if i were in her shoes. You seem obsessively determined to be looking for something wrong with this movie.
"13. Speaking of Krall, his whole narrative is that only hulking Neanderthals believe in fighting wars. Star Fleet is about peace...which is why their ships are heavily armed."
Dude, freedom isn't free. Even the hippie Jedi goes around carrying lightsabers. So you think that if you are about peace, you should disarm yourself?!? If you have nothing to hide you should also let the government spy on you right?!? I don't get all your nitpicking.
"14. Kirk didn't shoot Krall when he could have and ended it. Instead, he let him talk for a while and activate the weapon."
Of course, they want to give us that dramatic mano-o-mano fight between the two. In a way though, i could understand why Kirk didn't shoot first and ask question later. Krall is a captain just like Kirk. A war hero just like Kirk. His service record, is of somebody that Kirk will admire and look up to. Kirk wants to believe in that redemption, in that core humanity. It is personal and deeply head-scratching for him that somebody like Balthazar can turn into this monster. Kirk wonders if that monster is inside of him as well. The same way we have a hard time processing how the great Teutonic Europe is voluntarily and actively committing suicide right now.
"15. They lost thousands of crew members (or at least only around 30-50 were left in the camp), yet everyone is celebrating at the end. And Starfleet is trusting Kirk with another ship."
Why not? It was a no-win scenario. A Kobayashi Maru scenario for Kirk and the Enterprise, and yet, they manage to survive it and further prevent the death of millions on York town. What do you think is the survival rate for a Tail gunner/pilot on combat air mission during world war 2? Around 4 weeks. They send Kirk on mission after mission with completely unknown parameters, and you don't expect him to have a high turnover rate in his crew? Kirk and the Enterprise are basically the suicide squad of the Federations.
"16. Krall's whole motivation (which wasn't explained well) was about individual struggle over unity. Kirk should have (in good storytelling) taken the opposite approach and proved it. Instead, he talked about unity yet the movie ends with a lone Kirk fighting Krall - individual struggle wins. And Krall contends that individual struggle is what is needed, yet his armada is a bunch of drones fighting in unison."
This criticism just makes zero sense.
"
17. The franklin was Krall's (then Balthazar Edison) old ship that crashed on the planet. In the hundred years since, he never tried to get it working and forgot where it was (a few miles away from his base). I really don't feel like replying to the rest of your "criticism" to be honest, it is taking too long, and i just think you want to nitpick for some weird reason."
Yeah, maybe because he wants to bury and really forget about the kind of honorable and decent man he used to be. He pathologically wants absolutely nothing to do with being a starfleet officer. He wants to bury all those things and forget about them all. For pete's sake, he doesn't even look human, he even took on a completely different name and language, culture, etc.
"18. The Enterprise, the flagship of the Federation, is hopelessly outgunned...again. And, again, it's by mining equipment."
So? It is the unknown. It could be outgunned by a farting blue space monster. A sufficiently advance mining equipment will kick ass. A mining equipment from America will destroy an entire fleet of Somalian warships.
"19. Sulu is a faeg."
It is a futuristic movie.
"20. The "NX" designation on the Franklin - that's nitpicking and would only bother a Trekkie."
I give you that.
.
(This post was last modified: 07-24-2016 09:44 AM by Herr Lucifer.)
|