Osiris said:
I have a background in law enforcement and I switched career paths a few years ago and am currently working in education at a major city public school. I still have my conceal and carry license, but I would never take a gun outside the home except to the range for practice (it's something fun I do with the bros from time to time). I've been in a lot of situations, at no point when I wasn't in uniform would a weapon have made a positive difference.
That is a wonderful theoretical argument to make, at least until you are actually placed in a life-threatening situation. After being accosted by three gang bangers, I might not be alive today if not for the presence of my Beretta. Once they saw the handgun, they decided that they had other things to do -- and other people to see. And yes, being alive has made "a positive difference" in my life.
Conceal and Carry: If you've taken any weapon training you know it takes time to draw and fire your weapon. Even someone trained and ready takes enough time to draw as it takes an attacker to move roughly 21ft.
I had plenty of time to see what was coming. Those gang bangers
wanted me to see what was coming. I changed directions three times to avoid them. Each time, they changed direction to intercept me. They were getting off on it. But you should have seen their faces when the role reversal occurred.
It makes no sense to make such theoretical arguments. Every scenario is different. Everyone should have the choice as to whether to defend themselves.