I agree with Muc, to an extent. He just said things in an adversarial tone as Mike said, so people who'd otherwise agree will feel a little animosity towards him.
The content on the forum is great. But you'll get far more satisfaction and value from friendships with people in person than you will from a series of lifestyle tips. Sure, the forum promotes improvement and even 'transformations,' but all that can be sped up and strengthened when you have real life guys spitting advice at you. The greatest value of the forum is meeting guys who are living and breathing the forum's mindset. For instance, I've done very little pussy traveling - and then I meet guys like Slubu in real life who are living it.
It can also be reassuring, that if you're not happy with your results, you check in with other guys and see them having issues too. Or you find a guy who is doing well, and he shares his hustle. You can divide your pussy experiments among several guys, instead of going it alone and trying to discover everything by yourself. Once you've got the game basics down, very local advice may make all the difference - go to this bar, mack at this mall, etc. I've made the effort to meet up with several local guys, and am almost always open to meeting new guys (though there have been a couple times where a guy I'd never met acted weird over phone/texts and I lost interest).
As far as game goes, the most relevant criterion to me is if he can seem cool in a group. If he has trouble closing, it won't really affect my results unless he's outright cockblocking. If he is a cool dude, I can wheel over sets of girls and it will work okay. Also, I think having a cool friend boosts your value, because girls are unsure of whether you're actually a cool guy - when they see you with another cool guy it sort of confirms your status.
I actually tried to get a few cool forum guys in a house together. It's been put on ice, but all the guys were cool and I know it would be an amazing time.