I think i'm the only one who isn't a frye fan...I've bought a couple boots from them through the years and the leather is so freaking hard it never breaks up and softens.
Yeah when Frye started getting big again a few years back I tried on a pair that a friend had bought. He loved my Daytons but didnt want to drop the cash on them so he went Frye instead. At that point he was in them for a couple weeks and when I put them on I was not too impressed.
Granted his were motorcycle black rebel types but yes the leather was hard as fuck and looked like they were meant for a polish instead of an oil (I need oil on my boots for the rain) so that alone killed them for me. But Frye does have a lot of different types of boot, so who knows.
As for me, as long as I buy boots that need to stand up to biking, rain, and shitkickings it will always be Daytons. My boots felt like slippers and I walked right out the factory with them on my feet feeling invincible.