Yeah I think you guys claiming WNB are nuts.
"She's trashy" So?
"She's had work done" So?
"She's had a kid" So?
"She's an attention whore" So? No one's talking about her being a soulmate or life partner.
That hip to waist ratio is insane. The one way I can meet you WNB guys in the middle is to see the original, untouched, unphotoshopped pics. If she's rippled with cellulite (and there's a good chance she is) if she got folds and flaps where there shouldn't be any, okay, I can see maintaining a WNB position.
But based on those pics, and those pics alone, she gets a VIGOROUS WB from me. If you didn't know who she was, she was just some random internet slut that someone posted in the "Would You Bang" thread, and you claimed WNB, you'd be laughed out of the thread. You'd be laughed at for even posting her pic.