Here's a summary of most of the Christian films in this thread. For the older movies, I've pasted Leonard Maltin's reviews because I've found over many years that nearly anything he rates 3 stars out of 4 or higher is worth watching. For the newer ones, I've pasted the Wiki synopses. They're in alphabetical order.
The Agony and the Ecstacy (1965)
140 min, no rating, color
Leonard Maltin review 2.5 stars out of 4:
Huge spectacle of Michelangelo's artistic conflicts with Pope Julius II has adequate acting overshadowed by meticulous production. Short documentary on artist's work precedes fragmentary drama based on bits of Irving Stone's novel. Starring Charlton Heston.
Amazing Grace (2007)
The true story of evangelical politician William Wilberforce, who fought to end slavery in the British Empire.
The Apostle (1997)
Starring, directed and written by Robert Duvall, who plays a preacher from Texas. After his happy life spins out of control, he changes his name, goes to Louisiana and starts preaching on the radio.
Barabbas (1962)
134 min, no rating, color
Leonard Maltin review 3 stars out of 4:
Lavish production, coupled with good script (based on Lagerkvist's novel) and generally fine acting by large cast make for engrossing, literate experience. Overly long. Starring Anthony Quinn.
The Bells of St. Mary's (1945)
126 min, no rating, black & white
Leonard Maltin review 3 stars out of 4:
Amiable if meandering sequel to Going My Way, with Father O'Malley assigned to a run-down parish where Bergman is the Sister Superior. Bing Cosby introduces the song "Aren't You Glad You're You?" Also shown in computer-colored version.
Ben Hur (1959)
212 min, no rating, color
Leonard Maltin review 3.5 stars out of 4:
Epic-scale rendering of Gen. Lew Wallace's "Tale of the Christ." Charlton Heston and Stephen Boyd are well matched as the proud Jew Ben-Hur and his boyhood friend Messala, whose blind allegiance to Rome turns him into a bitter enemy. Poky at times, but redeemed by the strength of its convictions. Some of the special effects show their age, though the galley-slave sequence, and climactic chariot race (directed by Andrew Marton and staged by the legendary stunt expert Yakima Canutt) are still great. Some TV prints expand to widescreen format for the 15-minute chariot race sequence only. Filmed in MGM Camera 65.
The Case for Christ (2017)
A 2017 American Christian drama film directed by Jon Gunn and written by Brian Bird, based on a true story that was inspired by the 1998 book of the same name by Lee Strobel. The film stars Mike Vogel, Erika Christensen, Faye Dunaway and Robert Forster, and follows an atheist journalist who looks to disprove his wife's Christian faith.
The Catholics (1973)
Leonard Maltin review (TV) Above Average [Maltin's ratings for TV are below, average, or above]:
78 min, no rating, color
Powerful futuristic religious drama pitting strong-willed abbot Trevor Howard against emissary-of-change Martin Sheen, sent by the Vatican to his secluded monastery. Wordy but thought-provoking; adapted by Brian Moore from his novel. Video title: The Conflict.
Demetrius and the Gladiators (1954)
101 min, no rating, color
Leonard Maltin review 2.5 stars out of 4:
Hokey sequel to The Robe has Emperor Caligula (Jay Robinson) searching for magic robe of Christ; Victor Mature dallies with royal Susan Hayward. CinemaScope.
Diary of a Country Priest (1950)
France, 120 min, no rating, black & white
Leonard Maltin review 3.5 stars out of 4:
The life and death of an unhappy young priest attempting to minister to his first parish in rural France. Slow-moving but rewarding, with brilliantly stylized direction. Robert Bresson also scripted.
Elder Joseph the Hesychast (2020)
The film depicts the life of an ascetic monk of Mt. Athos who recently has been canonised a Saint by the Ecumenical Patriarchate. The title of the film bears his monastic name: Elder Joseph the Hesychas
The Flowers of Saint Francis (1950)
Italy, 89 minutes, no rating, black & white
A series of vignettes depicting the lives of the original Franciscan monks, including their leader and the bumbling Ginepro. Directed by Roberto Rossellini and co-written by Federico Fellini.
Going My Way (1944)
126 min, no rating, black & white
Leonard Maltin review 4 stars out of 4:
Sentimental story of down-to-earth priest Father O'Malley (Bing Crosby) winning over aging superior (Barry Fitzgerald) and sidewalk gang of kids is hard to resist—thanks to the skills of writer-director McCarey, who won two Oscars. Academy Awards also went to Crosby, Fitzgerald, Best Picture, and Best Song: "Swinging on a Star." Sequel: The Bells of St. Mary'S.
The Gospel According to St. Matthew (1966)
France-Italy, 135 min, no rating, black & white
Leonard Maltin review 4 stars out of 4:
Unconventional, austere film on life and teachings of Christ, based solely on writings of the Apostle, Matthew. Amateur cast (including director's mother) is expressive and moves with quiet dignity. Ironically, director of this masterpiece was a Marxist.
Inn of the Sixth Happiness (1958)
158 min, no rating, color
Leonard Maltin review 3 stars out of 4:
True story of English servant (Ingrid Bergman) who, despite her lack of credentials, realizes her dream of becoming a missionary in China.
The Island (2006) (Russian: Остров, romanized: Ostrov)
A 2006 Russian film about a fictional 20th century Eastern Orthodox monk in an obscure monastery, who is considered to be a holy man able to pray for immediate cures and give sage advice. Probably the best film depicting healing through prayer, as well as Christian clairvoyance and premonition/discernment.
Jesus of Nazareth (1977)
TV mini-series, 6+ hours
A 1977 British-Italian epic film and television drama serial directed by Franco Zeffirelli and co-written by Zeffirelli, Anthony Burgess, and Suso Cecchi d'Amico which dramatizes the birth, life, ministry, crucifixion and resurrection of Jesus. It stars Robert Powell as Jesus, and features an all-star cast of actors, including eight who had won or would go on to win Academy Awards: Anne Bancroft, Ernest Borgnine, Laurence Olivier, Christopher Plummer, Anthony Quinn, Rod Steiger, James Earl Jones, and Peter Ustinov.
King of Kings (1961)
168 min, no rating, color
Leonard Maltin review 3.5 stars out of 4:
The life of Christ, intelligently told and beautifully filmed; full of deeply moving moments, such as the Sermon on the Mount, Christ's healing of the lame, and many others. Memorable Miklos Rozsa score. Not without flaws, but well worthwhile; grandly filmed in widescreen Super Technirama 70. Narrated by Orson Welles, Roberty Ryan as John the Baptist, and Rip Torn as Judas Escariot.
Lilies of the Field (1963)
93 min, no rating, black & white
Leonard Maltin review 3 stars out of 4:
A "little" film that made good, winning Sidney Poitier an Oscar as handyman who helps build a chapel for the Abbess (Lilia Skala) and her German-speaking nuns. Quiet, well acted, enjoyable. Director Nelson followed this with a TV movie, Christmas Lilies of the Field.
A Man for All Seasons (1966)
UK, 120 min, no rating, color
Leonard Maltin review 4 stars out of 4:
Splendid film based on Robert Bolt's play about Sir Thomas More's personal conflict when King Henry VIII asks his support in break with Pope and formation of Church of England. Scofield's rich characterization matched by superb cast, vivid atmosphere. Six Oscars include Best Actor, Director, Picture, Screenplay (Robert Bolt), Cinematography (Ted Moore), Costumes. Remade for TV in 1988.
The Miracle of Our Lady of Fatima (1952)
102 min, no rating, color
Leonard Maltin review 3 stars out of 4:
Thoughtful account of religious miracle witnessed by farm children in 1910s; intelligent script. Retitled: Miracle of Fatima.
My Night at Maud's (1969)
France, 105 min, Rated PG, black & white
No. 3 of Eric Rohmer's "Six Moral Tales" is most intellectual, with Jean-Louis Trintignant as moral Catholic man infatuated with woman completely unlike himself. Talky, fascinating, more specialized in appeal than later entries in series. Marrie Christine Barrault's first film.
Ordet (1955)
Denmark, 125 min, no rating, black & white
Leonard Maltin review 4 stars out of 4:
Two rural families, at odds with each other over religious differences, are forced to come to grips with their children's love for each other. Arguably Director Carl Theodor Dreyer's greatest film, but certainly the movies' final word on the struggle between conventional Christianity and more personalized religious faith. Truly awe-inspiring, with a never-to-be-forgotten climactic scene. Based on a play by Kaj Munk, which was filmed before in 1943.
Paul, Apostle of Christ (2018)
106 minutes, color, starring Jim Caviezel. I give this 4 out of 4 stars.
Caviezel plays Luke the Evangelist, who has come to Rome in order to speak with St. Paul, who has been imprisoned by Nero. Great script, great acting, great film on a small budget.
Quo Vadis? (1951)
171 min, no rating, color
Leonard Maltin review 3 stars out of 4:
Gargantuan MGM adaptation of Henryk Sienkiewicz' novel set during the reign of Nero; Roman soldier Taylor has to figure out how to romance Christian Kerr without both of them ending up as lunch for the lions. Meticulous production includes fine location shooting and Miklos Rozsa score based on music of the era. Remade for Italian TV.
Risen (2016)
A 2016 American biblical drama film directed by Kevin Reynolds and written by Reynolds and Paul Aiello. The film stars Joseph Fiennes, Tom Felton, Peter Firth, and Cliff Curtis, and details a Roman soldier's search for Yeshua's body following his resurrection. Columbia Pictures released the film to theaters in the United States on February 19, 2016. It received mixed reviews and grossed $46 million worldwide.
The Robe (1953)
135 min, no rating, color
Leonard Maltin review 2.5 stars out of 4:
Earnest but episodic costume drama from Lloyd C. Douglas novel about Roman centurion who presides over Christ's crucifixion. Burton's Oscar-nominated performance seems stiff and superficial today, while Mature (as his slave Demetrius) comes off quite well! Famed as first movie in CinemaScope, though it was simultaneously shot "flat." Sequel: Demetrius and the Gladiators.
The Ten Commandments (1956)
220 min, no rating, color
Leonard Maltin review 4 stars out of 4:
Vivid storytelling at its best. Biblical epic follows Moses' life from birth and abandonment through manhood, slavery, and trials in leading the Jews out of Egypt. Few subtleties in De Mille's second handling of this tale (first filmed in 1923) but few lulls, either. Parting of the Red Sea (De Mille's second!), writing of the holy tablets are unforgettable highlights. Oscar-winning special effects. VistaVision.
The Way (2010)
123 minutes, color, written and directed by Emilio Estevez, starring his father Martin Sheen. I give it 2.5/4 stars and agree with Kirk Honeycutt of The Hollywood Reporter, who wrote a mixed review, stating: "Emilio Estevez's The Way is an earnest film, its heart always in the right place, but it's severely under dramatized." Difficult to avoid spoilers here. Sheen's character walks part of the real Christian pilgrimage route Camino de Santiago, and encounters fellow travelers from France to Spain. The setting of the film is Christian even if the pilgrims who make up the cast are not the most devout, but are more like a typical collection of oddballs in a road-trip movie.