I seriously believe the United States and its freedoms and constitution was founded on the pretext of a Protestant nation. Remove that, it all falls apart.
Separation of church and state was put in place because the founders of America were about as removed from the 30 years war as we are the civil war. Religious violence was scary - go look up the atrocities committed in the 30 years war. Sweet dreams guys.
They never intended us to be a secular atheistic state. They decided to put the wall between church and state up because 1. They wanted to avoid factional violence “a la 30 years war” 2. They assumed we’d always have a default Protestant background. In fact, even though I’m Orthodox and believe Protestantism has errors, I would be cool if with legally enshrining it because of its essential character of our country.
Even though it’s loaded with heterodoxy - no Protestant religion - no America. Also, I’m not cheerleading for Protestantism. I’m convinced an Orthodox state would be very different and would possibly avoid ending up in the situation America is in now.
Yes, the founders couldn't have conceived of America having anything but a Christian culture. Arguably it was a Christian country until the 20th century. Had the founders known how much things would change they would have put stronger safeguards in place. For example, I don't believe that they would have allowed the first amendment to protect pornography if they knew that that's how it would be used. Same with abortion. Or single women voting. Those things were unthinkable in the 18th century.
Last edited: