RE: This is why you must train a
I was actually responding to the spirit of this thread which started out with a shameful video of an American con artist posing as a Karate master and the implication that karate is - as a result - "ego delusion" and some commented that boxing is somehow more realistic. So, I offer a specific example - "fighting with empty hand" to show that Karate is a realistic self defense. My intent is not to show that boxing is inferior. Boxing is a great sport. There is nothing wrong with sport but sports have rules and necessary protective gear, and it shouldn't be confused with self defense.
samsamsam said:^^ Aren't those practitioners who break those boards/bricks allowed time to prepare for the blow? Meaning it always seems like they are allowed as much time as needed to rehearse before hitting it. When do you get that chance in a real fight? "Hold on a second, I need about 30 seconds to prepare my death blow."
My experience of the people commenting on boxing is one of sharing information. However, you seem to be coming from a place of how much better your choice of self defense is superior to anything else. Which can never be proven. But you seem dead set on making sure that whatever you have invested time in is superior to protect your ego. I thought martial arts was to teach you not to have an ego, not to engage in unnecessary "confrontations", etc.
Anyway here is a guy breaking some bricks using a towel to protect his hand.
I was actually responding to the spirit of this thread which started out with a shameful video of an American con artist posing as a Karate master and the implication that karate is - as a result - "ego delusion" and some commented that boxing is somehow more realistic. So, I offer a specific example - "fighting with empty hand" to show that Karate is a realistic self defense. My intent is not to show that boxing is inferior. Boxing is a great sport. There is nothing wrong with sport but sports have rules and necessary protective gear, and it shouldn't be confused with self defense.